Mother’s Day has always been a time to celebrate the women who nurture, support, and care for us through thick and thin. It’s a day where we honor the unwavering strength, patience, and love that mothers provide to their children, families, and communities. For many, this day holds deep sentimental value as it allows us to express gratitude to the women who played vital roles in our lives.

However, in recent years, there has been an increasing tendency to shift the focus of Mother’s Day beyond its traditional bounds. A growing movement pushes to include men, especially those who identify as transgender women, in the celebration. While the intention behind this inclusion may stem from a desire for recognition and equality, it raises a larger question about the preservation of gender-specific holidays and their unique meanings.

Mother’s Day, as the name suggests, is fundamentally for mothers. It’s a day dedicated to celebrating the contributions of biological and adoptive mothers—individuals who bear the responsibility of raising children, providing emotional support, and creating the foundation for future generations. This day symbolizes the gratitude society has for the maternal sacrifices that often go unrecognized throughout the year.

The notion of Mother’s Day as a celebration for women is rooted in the biology of motherhood. Women give birth to children, a process that has an undeniable impact on their physical, emotional, and psychological well-being. The bond between a mother and her child is often one of the most profound connections humans experience. In addition to the physical aspect, mothers are typically tasked with the emotional labor of nurturing and guiding their children into adulthood. From sleepless nights to the constant demands of balancing careers and home life, mothers sacrifice so much for the well-being of their families.

That said, some individuals argue that extending the celebration of motherhood to include men in dresses undermines the significance of the day. Critics believe that redefining Mother’s Day to accommodate gender fluidity or inclusivity of transgender individuals detracts from the essence of the holiday. When Mother’s Day becomes about something other than mothers—whether it be men who have chosen to wear dresses or other gender expressions—it risks diluting the celebration of women’s unique role in society.

It’s essential to understand that this is not an attack on transgender individuals or their rights. The debate centers around the preservation of holidays that serve a specific purpose in society. There is a time and place to celebrate everyone, including transgender individuals, but it’s vital to keep in mind the original intent of holidays like Mother’s Day. The question isn’t about being anti-transgender; rather, it’s about honoring the traditional meaning of the day.

For those who advocate for an inclusive approach, their argument usually stems from the belief that gender roles are societal constructs that should be fluid. They assert that motherhood isn’t solely tied to biological factors, and that anyone, regardless of gender, can step into a maternal role. However, while it’s true that anyone can take on roles traditionally associated with mothers—such as providing care, love, and support—Mother’s Day celebrates a very specific reality: the unique experiences of women who bear the responsibility of giving birth, raising children, and handling the multifaceted duties that come with being a mother.

In this context, acknowledging men in dresses or transgender women during Mother’s Day can be seen as an attempt to broaden the concept of motherhood in ways that may undermine the significance of what it means to be a mother in the traditional sense. Rather than extending the holiday, perhaps it’s time to create additional days to honor those who feel left out—Transgender Day of Remembrance, for example, exists to honor and reflect on the lives of transgender individuals, highlighting their struggles and contributions to society. But trying to redefine Mother’s Day could lead to further division and the erosion of what it stands for.

Let us not forget that, while gender fluidity and inclusivity are essential topics in modern society, the observance of a holiday with its roots deeply embedded in a biological and cultural reality should be respected. Mother’s Day is for those women who experience the struggles, triumphs, and challenges of raising children. It’s their day to be honored for the sacrifices they make day in and day out, for the lifelong journey of motherhood they embark on the moment they bring their child into the world.

As the calendar rolls around to May, let’s remember that there is a specific place for the celebration of motherhood, and it should be honored for what it represents—a tribute to women and their irreplaceable roles in shaping the future. The inclusive nature of today’s society should be celebrated, but let us not forget that Mother’s Day, like any other holiday, has its roots in something deeply meaningful, and it is this tradition that we should continue to honor.

While men in dresses deserve their time to shine and be recognized for their individual contributions, Mother’s Day remains a sacred space for those who have borne the title of ‘mother’ in its truest sense. It is their day. Their sacrifices should not be overshadowed or diluted by the need to accommodate a broader cultural shift. Their contributions are worth recognizing on their own terms, in their own space, on their own day. So, let us be respectful and mindful of what Mother’s Day truly stands for—and remember, their day is now.