As the release of James Gunn’s Superman film approaches on July 11, 2025, the reintroduction of the iconic red trunks in David Corenswet’s costume has sparked a timely debate about the appropriateness of superhero attire in today’s cultural landscape. Once a symbol of strength and tradition, the red underwear, a staple of Superman’s look since his 1938 debut, feels increasingly out of step with modern sensibilities, raising questions about its suitability for both children and adults in 2025. With evolving fashion standards, heightened awareness of body image, and shifting parental concerns, the return of this classic design element has ignited discussions online and beyond, challenging whether it still holds relevance in a contemporary context.
The red trunks originated as a practical solution in the early days of comic printing, when limited color palettes and thick outlines were used to distinguish body parts, particularly the groin and buttocks. Inspired by the circus strongmen of the 1930s, who wore tight shorts over tights to emphasize their physique, the design became a hallmark of Superman’s costume, later influencing characters like Batman and Wonder Woman. For decades, it was celebrated as a nostalgic nod to superhero origins, with brands like Underoos even turning it into a playful children’s product. However, as graphic technology advanced and superhero aesthetics evolved—most notably with Zack Snyder’s trunk-less Man of Steel suit in 2013—the trunks began to feel like a relic, often mocked as an outdated fashion faux pas.
In 2025, this perception has only intensified. Parents and educators are increasingly mindful of the messages clothing sends to young audiences, especially regarding body consciousness and gender norms. The idea of a superhero flaunting red underwear might have been a quirky charm in the past, but today it risks being seen as inappropriate or even embarrassing for kids, who are more exposed to diverse media and peer scrutiny. Social media posts found on X reflect this shift, with some users joking about the trunks’ return while others question its relevance, suggesting it might alienate younger viewers accustomed to sleeker, more streamlined designs. The baggy fit observed in set photos of Corenswet’s suit has further fueled the critique, with some arguing it amplifies the awkwardness rather than modernizing the look.
For adults, the debate takes on additional layers. While some fans embrace the trunks as a tribute to Superman’s comic roots, others see them as a dated trope that clashes with current tastes favoring minimalism and sophistication. The trunks’ association with circus attire, once a badge of strength, now feels more like a carnival gimmick to some, especially as superhero films compete with high-budget, realistic blockbusters. This sentiment is echoed in online discussions about whether the design aligns with the mature storytelling trends of the DC Universe’s new chapter, “Gods and Monsters.” Critics argue that a superhero in 2025 should project a more polished image, free from elements that might invite ridicule or undermine the character’s gravitas.
Gunn’s decision to reinstate the trunks reflects his intent to reconnect with Superman’s hopeful, classic persona, but it risks misfiring in a world where cultural norms have shifted. The film’s trailers, showcasing a brighter suit and a younger Clark Kent, aim to inspire, yet the underwear element has drawn mixed reactions, with some parents expressing reluctance to let their children emulate the look. Alternatives like the New 52’s trunk-less design or Cavill’s armored suit are cited as more fitting for a modern audience, offering a balance of tradition and relevance without the potential for awkwardness. Even within the comic community, the trunks’ return in Action Comics #1000 in 2018 was met with mixed reviews, hinting at a broader fatigue with the trope.
As the film’s release nears, the conversation continues to evolve. Some defend the trunks as a harmless link to the past, while others advocate for a redesign that respects today’s values. The appropriateness of a superhero in red underwear in 2025 hinges on this tension between nostalgia and progress, leaving fans and families to ponder whether Superman’s classic look can still save the day or if it’s time to retire it for good.
