The internet has been ablaze with controversy following the release of the latest trailer for The Last of Us Season 2, where a single line delivered by Bella Ramsey’s character, Ellie, has sparked a wave of memes and heated debate. The line, “I’m gonna be a Dad,” uttered in a pivotal scene, was intended to carry significant emotional weight, reflecting Ellie’s complex journey in the adaptation of the critically acclaimed video game The Last of Us Part II. However, the line’s delivery and context have been met with widespread mockery online, transforming it into a viral meme. Ramsey, the 21-year-old star known for their powerful performances in Game of Thrones and The Last of Us, has expressed outrage over the memes, labeling them as disrespectful and harmful. In a bold move, Ramsey has demanded legal action against individuals and organizations responsible for creating and spreading the memes, igniting a broader conversation about the boundaries of online humor and celebrity privacy.
The controversy began shortly after HBO dropped the Season 2 trailer in early May 2025, showcasing Ellie’s evolving role in a post-apocalyptic world. The “I’m gonna be a Dad” line, drawn from a moment meant to highlight Ellie’s emotional depth and the weight of her choices, struck many viewers as jarring. Social media platforms, particularly X, exploded with memes juxtaposing Ramsey’s delivery with humorous captions, GIFs, and edited clips, often poking fun at the line’s perceived incongruity with the show’s typically grim tone. Posts on X, including one from user @ChristianPL21, highlighted the extent of the ridicule, with fans and critics alike sharing lighthearted but biting commentary. While some fans defended Ramsey’s performance, arguing that the line’s context would resonate more in the full episode, the meme culture quickly spiraled, overshadowing the trailer’s intended impact.
Ramsey, who uses they/them pronouns, addressed the issue in a candid interview with Variety on May 18, 2025, expressing deep frustration with the memes. “It’s not just a joke—it’s personal,” Ramsey said. “This scene was one of the hardest I’ve ever filmed, and to see it reduced to a punchline by people who don’t even understand the story is infuriating.” Ramsey emphasized that the memes felt like a targeted attack on their performance and identity, particularly given the gendered implications of the “Dad” line in a narrative that explores Ellie’s queerness. They called for accountability, urging their legal team to pursue lawsuits against individuals or entities that “intentionally teased” or profited from the memes, including meme pages and content creators with significant followings. While Ramsey did not name specific targets, their statement has raised questions about the feasibility of such legal action in the nebulous world of internet culture.
The backlash against the memes has divided fans. Supporters of Ramsey argue that the memes trivialize a sensitive moment in Ellie’s arc, which in the game deals with themes of parenthood, loss, and identity. They point to Ramsey’s acclaimed Season 1 performance as evidence of their ability to carry the role, suggesting that the full context of Season 2, set to premiere in June 2025, will vindicate the line’s inclusion. Critics, however, contend that the line’s delivery and writing, as seen in the trailer, failed to convey the necessary gravitas, making it ripe for satire. A StarTeFacts article noted that the show’s writers may have misjudged the tone, turning a potentially powerful scene into an unintended lightning rod for criticism. Regardless, the memes have undeniably shifted focus from the show’s narrative to Ramsey’s personal response.
Legal experts have weighed in, noting that Ramsey’s pursuit of lawsuits faces significant hurdles. Defamation or harassment claims would require proof of malicious intent and tangible harm, which is difficult to establish in the context of memes. Free speech protections, particularly in the U.S., further complicate matters, as parody and satire are often shielded. Posts on X reflect mixed sentiments, with some users sympathizing with Ramsey’s hurt while others defend the memes as harmless fan expression. The controversy has also reignited debates about the pressures young actors face in the age of social media, where performances are scrutinized and memed in real time.
As The Last of Us Season 2 approaches, Ramsey’s response has cast a shadow over the show’s promotion. HBO has yet to comment officially, but showrunner Craig Mazin has hinted at standing by the creative choices, suggesting that viewers “wait for the full story.” For Ramsey, the fight is personal, a stand against the dehumanizing side of internet fame. Whether their legal threats materialize or not, this saga underscores the delicate balance between artistic intent and public perception in the digital era.
